Mariah Carey, a global music icon, has always captivated the world with her dazzling voice and glamorous persona. However, behind the fame and fortune, lies a complex family dynamic, particularly her relationships with her siblings, Alison and Morgan Carey. Before the tragic passing of her sister Alison in August 2024, Mariah’s connection with both her siblings was marked by both affection and significant challenges, as detailed in her 2020 memoir, The Meaning of Mariah Carey.
Early Family Life and Sibling Dynamics
Born the youngest of three children to Patricia and Alfred Carey, Mariah entered a family already navigating its own complexities. Her brother Morgan was born in 1960, followed by her sister Alison in 1963, and Mariah completed the trio in 1969. The Carey family initially resided in Long Island, New York, setting the stage for their formative years.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(768×122:770×124)/mariah-carey-tout-041324-0c16e2852dba4ab7a33fd65eb8e79837.jpg)
The family structure shifted dramatically when Mariah was just three years old, as her parents divorced. Mariah primarily lived with her Irish-American mother, while her Afro-Venezuelan father’s presence became less consistent in her daily life. This parental separation contributed to a sense of disconnect and isolation for young Mariah within her own family. As she shared in The Oprah Conversation, reflecting on her childhood, she felt like an “outsider” among her siblings, who, in her view, had already experienced considerable hardship by the time she was born. She perceived their journeys as distinct and marked by damage, further emphasizing the emotional distance she felt. Mariah also suggested that her siblings might have perceived her upbringing as easier due to her primarily living with their white mother, contrasting with their experiences of growing up in a biracial household earlier on.
Memoir “The Meaning of Mariah Carey” and Family Conflicts
Mariah’s memoir, The Meaning of Mariah Carey, released in 2020, offered a candid and at times painful look into her family relationships. She openly discussed her “turbulent relationship” with Alison, describing her sister as both “deeply wounded” and “the most brilliant and broken person.” Mariah recounted Alison’s exposure to traumatic events in childhood, experiences that Mariah believed profoundly impacted Alison’s life and well-being. According to Mariah, Alison witnessed distressing situations before Mariah’s birth, which she believes “damaged and derailed her girlhood.” She emphasized Alison’s awareness and absorption of the pain as their family unit fractured.
The memoir also contained serious allegations regarding Alison’s struggles with drug addiction. Mariah claimed that Alison had introduced her to drugs at a young age, recounting disturbing incidents of alleged drug use and endangerment. These were weighty claims that painted a picture of a deeply troubled relationship between the sisters.
Furthermore, Mariah addressed her relationship with her brother Morgan in her memoir, detailing instances of alleged violence. She described an incident where Morgan purportedly pushed their mother with such force that she lost consciousness. Another alleged altercation involved Morgan and their father, Alfred, escalating to a point requiring police intervention. These accounts presented a family history marked by volatility and conflict.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(814×0:816×2)/mariah-carey-2524a079cd8f43218b58dd619717b2a1.jpg)
Lawsuits and Public Disputes
The publication of The Meaning of Mariah Carey ignited further family conflict, leading to legal battles. Alison Carey initiated a lawsuit against Mariah in February 2021, seeking $1.25 million and alleging intentional infliction of emotional distress. Alison argued that Mariah’s memoir contained stories that were deliberately humiliating and caused her severe emotional pain. She claimed the book exacerbated her existing trauma, leading to depression and a relapse into alcohol abuse after a period of sobriety.
Shortly after Alison’s lawsuit, Morgan Carey also filed a defamation lawsuit against Mariah in March 2021. Morgan asserted that Mariah’s portrayal of him in the memoir was false and damaging, costing him professional opportunities. He specifically disputed Mariah’s characterization of him as violent and argued that it was a calculated attempt to align herself with the Black Lives Matter movement while vilifying him.
Mariah responded to Morgan’s lawsuit by stating that her intention was to “inspire” readers with her story of overcoming adversity, not to defame her brother. However, Morgan countered this claim, arguing that her omission of his personal struggles, including cerebral palsy and epilepsy, undermined her purported inspirational intent. He accused Mariah of prioritizing book sales and her public image at his expense, disregarding the truth and his well-being. These legal disputes underscored the deep rifts within the Mariah Carey Family and the public nature of their conflicts.
Morgan Carey’s Life in Italy
Amidst the family turmoil, details emerged about Morgan Carey’s life away from the spotlight. According to his 2021 lawsuit, Morgan had relocated to Italy with his wife, Ilaria, in 2012. There, they were pursuing creative endeavors, working on screenplays and a book focused on permaculture, fitness, and lifestyle. However, Morgan claimed that the negative publicity generated by Mariah’s memoir had detrimental effects on his and his wife’s careers. He alleged that promising negotiations for their screenplay projects were abruptly terminated following the publication of the book, attributing this to the damage Mariah’s “libelous vitriol” inflicted upon his reputation. Morgan expressed concern that the public humiliation from Mariah’s accusations would have lasting negative consequences on his professional and personal interactions.
The Passing of Alison and Patricia Carey
In a heartbreaking turn of events, August 2024 brought profound loss to Mariah Carey and her family. She announced the passing of both her mother, Patricia, and her sister, Alison, on the same day. Mariah shared a public statement expressing her devastation and grief over the simultaneous loss of her mother and sister. She mentioned feeling blessed to have spent the preceding week with her mother before her passing and requested privacy during this incredibly difficult time.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(1004×613:1006×615)/mariah-carey-mom-tout-0082c694bc6944049931bbc174c2da87.jpg)
Details surrounding Alison’s death revealed that she had been in hospice care in Coxsackie, New York, and passed away at her home. A close friend, David Baker, shared that Alison’s health had declined rapidly in the month leading up to her death. Despite the anticipation of her passing, it remained a shock for those close to her. Baker also noted that Alison’s children had visited her in her final weeks, with her daughter providing daily support. Reflecting on Alison’s relationship with Mariah, Baker recounted that Alison believed her last meeting with Mariah was either in 2002 or even as far back as 1994, highlighting the extended period of estrangement between the sisters.
The Mariah Carey family story is one marked by immense talent, global fame, and also significant personal challenges and heartbreaks. The complexities of sibling relationships, amplified by public scrutiny and personal struggles, have shaped the Carey family narrative. The recent loss of Alison and Patricia adds another layer of sorrow to this already intricate family history.
