The story of The Family I Had unfolds with a chilling premise that could easily be mistaken for a sensationalized Hollywood thriller. Yet, for the Lee family, it is a stark and devastating reality. In 2007, their lives were irrevocably shattered when 13-year-old Paris violently murdered his four-year-old sister, Ella, on Super Bowl Sunday. This unimaginable act of violence is further shadowed by the tragic history of their mother, Charity, who herself experienced childhood trauma when her father was murdered, and her mother became a suspect in a mafia-related crime. In the gripping documentary The Family I Had, directed by Katie Green and Carlye Rubin, we are given an unflinching look at a family grappling with the incomprehensible, resulting in a profoundly moving and heartbreaking cinematic experience.
The documentary opens with poignant home video footage capturing Paris and Ella joyfully unwrapping Christmas gifts, a bittersweet reminder of happier times before the horrific crime that irrevocably fractured their family. The innocence of these childhood memories is brutally juxtaposed with the chilling 911 call made by Paris after the murder, a moment that sends shivers down your spine. However, it is Charity’s raw and emotionally charged account of being informed by the police about the brutal events at her home that truly devastates. In some of the most profoundly disturbing scenes, Charity recounts the moment her world collapsed, losing both of her children in a single, catastrophic event that would forever alter the family’s trajectory.
Beyond the Crime: Exploring the Aftermath in The Family I Had
The Family I Had is undeniably a difficult film to watch, and the emotional weight of its opening scenes lingers throughout. However, the documentary takes a nuanced approach, shifting its focus from the sensationalism of the crime itself to the complex aftermath and the family’s arduous journey toward healing. It meticulously examines Charity’s relationship with her incarcerated son, Paris; the fraught dynamic with her mother, Kyla, who attempted to gain guardianship of Paris; and her unwavering commitment to her youngest son, Phoenix, born after Ella’s death, as she strives to shield him from the darkness of crime and mental illness that has plagued their family.
A significant strength of The Family I Had lies in its authentic and intimate portrayal, largely achieved through deeply personal one-on-one interviews with the central figures. Charity serves as the audience’s emotional anchor, guiding us through the devastating sequence of events with remarkable candor. Paris, speaking from prison with an unsettlingly calm demeanor, reflects on the crime and its far-reaching consequences. Kyla, the children’s grandmother, provides crucial context by revealing a troubling history of crime within the Lee family, shedding light on the strained relationship she shares with her daughter, Charity.
Charity emerges as an incredibly sympathetic figure. Her inherent warmth, resilience, and boundless love for all three of her children – including Phoenix, born after the tragedy – resonate deeply. Her willingness to share her profound pain with such openness is a testament to the sensitive and skillful direction of Green and Rubin. Their ability to create a safe space for Charity to articulate her most excruciating experiences is what elevates The Family I Had from a true crime documentary to a deeply insightful and emotionally resonant human story.
Authentic Direction and Intimate Storytelling
Green and Rubin have openly acknowledged that The Family I Had evolved significantly from its initial conception. Originally intended to explore the juvenile criminal justice system, the filmmakers made a conscious decision to pivot towards the more personal and intimate narrative of the Lee family as production progressed. This shift in focus resulted in a poignant and contemplative exploration of family bonds, unconditional love, and the complexities of coping with unimaginable loss. The filmmakers consciously avoided sensationalizing the Lee family’s tragedy for dramatic effect, instead prioritizing an authentic and empathetic portrayal of their heartbreak and resilience.
While the documentary grapples with the unfathomable circumstances surrounding the crime, it also delves into profound and universal themes. The age-old debate of nature versus nurture is thoughtfully explored, carefully examining potential factors that may have contributed to Paris’s violent outburst. Did a predisposition towards crime run in the family, or were environmental factors, perhaps the arrival of his sister and the perceived shift in parental attention, the catalyst? The Family I Had subtly raises these complex questions, enriching the documentary with layers of intellectual and emotional depth without offering easy answers.
Paris himself grapples with these questions during his disconcerting yet compelling interviews. Charity, in turn, confronts the agonizing dilemma of whether to allow Phoenix to ever meet Paris. Could she responsibly and safely permit her son to have a relationship with the brother who murdered his sister? It is in these intimate, smaller moments that the immense scale of the tragedy truly resonates, amplified by the documentary’s stark and unflinching approach.
The documentary’s masterful structure is crucial to its impact. The Family I Had seamlessly navigates different timelines, moving between past, present, and future with remarkable clarity and control, never losing the viewer in its non-linear approach. Details are strategically revealed throughout the film, not merely for dramatic effect, but in a way that feels organic and true to the unfolding process of understanding such a complex tragedy. This deliberate pacing prevents information overload, allowing the audience the necessary emotional space to absorb the devastating details of the crime and its aftermath.
Conclusion: The Enduring Power of The Family I Had
While The Family I Had may move away from the initial shock value after its opening moments, the profound impact of the tragedy and its intricate layers of complexity remain powerfully present throughout the film. Green and Rubin demonstrate exceptional skill and sensitivity as directors, guiding the narrative with confidence and empathy. Despite minor pacing issues, where some revelations feel somewhat underdeveloped, the deeply personal interviews and intimate exploration of the Lee family’s experience are central to the documentary’s profound success. The Family I Had is a sensitively crafted and deeply thoughtful film, undeniably harrowing, yet all the more impactful for its unflinching honesty. The individuals at the heart of this story bravely share their painful memories and open wounds, revealing the enduring impact of the tragedy and the constant reminders that will forever shape their lives.
Green and Rubin never lose sight of the agonizing tragedy at the core of The Family I Had, and it is this unwavering focus that makes the documentary so profoundly effective. Emotionally draining yet ultimately illuminating, The Family I Had is a powerful cinematic experience. It is a devastatingly sad story, yet within the darkness, a faint glimmer of hope emerges – a testament to the resilience of the human spirit and the enduring power of unconditional love, embodied by Charity Lee’s extraordinary strength in the face of unimaginable adversity.
Watch The Family I Had
