Fans of Modern Family often revisit the early seasons for comfort, charmed by the witty writing and relatable characters. Seasons one through five are particularly cherished for their consistent quality and heartwarming humor. Among the many beloved storylines, the potential romance between Haley Dunphy (Sarah Hyland) and Andy Bailey (Adam Devine) stands out as a fan favorite. However, the direction Haley’s character took, especially concerning her romantic relationships, has been a point of contention for many viewers. Some feel her character development faltered in later seasons, deviating from the promising paths hinted at in earlier episodes. The relationship with Andy, in particular, resonated with audiences who appreciated their organic connection and mutual support. Therefore, their eventual separation was a significant disappointment for those invested in their potential.
This very topic resurfaced when Adam Devine responded to a fan on social media who expressed dismay over the Haley/Andy storyline’s conclusion, even suggesting Devine’s departure was to blame. While acknowledging that his exit did impact the storyline, Devine clarified that it wasn’t due to him leaving the show permanently. According to Devine’s tweet, the writers had considered bringing his character back towards the series finale. However, scheduling conflicts with another project prevented his return. Devine tweeted, “Offense TAKEN. Hehe. They wanted to bring me back towards the end of the show but I was already shooting another project. Hollywood baby!!! Sarah rules. The show ruled and I loved being a part of it.” This revelation sparks the question: did the writers originally envision a different outcome for Haley and Andy?
Devine’s comment suggests that alternative storylines were indeed considered. Many viewers have long imagined a scenario where Haley and Andy ended up together, finding it a more compelling and natural progression than other romantic arcs Haley experienced, or even storylines involving other characters like Alex and her professor. The sentiment that Haley “deserved better” than some of the plot decisions made for her character, especially in romance, is a common one among Modern Family enthusiasts. While Adam Devine’s tweet doesn’t definitively confirm a planned Haley/Andy endgame, it does hint at the possibility of a different direction and perhaps offers some solace to fans who wished for a different romantic trajectory for Haley Dunphy in Modern Family.
