It’s a sentiment that has likely echoed in the minds of many long-time viewers: is Modern Family past its prime? Episode 21 of Season 9, “The Escape,” unfortunately does little to dispel this notion. For those who have found themselves increasingly detached from the privileged tribulations of the Pritchett-Delgado-Tucker clan, this episode may feel like another confirmation of the show’s struggle to remain relatable and genuinely funny. The episode, airing on May 9, 2018, puts the spotlight squarely on the characters’ capacity for petty squabbles and self-absorbed behavior, a characteristic that has become more grating than endearing as the seasons have progressed.
The premise of “The Escape” revolves around the family’s often-forced interactions and their predictable descent into interpersonal conflict. What was once perceived as quirky family dynamics now often translates into characters being deliberately unpleasant to one another. The humor, which once thrived on relatable family mishaps and heartwarming resolutions, now feels strained and manufactured, particularly when the show insists on portraying this group as a loving and supportive family unit. This dissonance between the intended message and the on-screen portrayal becomes increasingly difficult to reconcile, diminishing the comedic impact and overall enjoyment of Modern Family season 9.
However, amidst the familiar frustrations, there remains a single bright spot: Haley Dunphy, portrayed with consistent brilliance by Sarah Hyland. Haley stands out as the most compelling character arc in Modern Family season 9, and arguably across the entire series. Unlike her family members who often seem stagnant or regress into caricature, Haley has demonstrably grown and evolved. Hyland’s performance is a masterclass in comedic timing and nuanced emotion, effortlessly shifting between comedic delivery and genuine vulnerability. Her expressive face and ability to embody a range of emotions – from ditzy charm to surprising strength and warmth – make Haley the most human and relatable character in the ensemble.
In “The Escape,” Haley’s storyline, though brief, provides a much-needed injection of genuine entertainment. Her reaction to Arvind’s insensitive behavior in front of his parents is a standout moment. Haley’s witty retort and self-assured exit (“I’ve been awarded a fellowship to the bathroom, and I’m accepting it!”) perfectly encapsulates her evolved personality: still funny, but now also self-respecting and assertive. This scene is a testament to both the writers’ occasional flashes of brilliance when it comes to Haley and Hyland’s impeccable delivery.
Yet, even Haley’s narrative thread is not without its shortcomings. The romantic relationship with Arvind, while providing some screen time for Haley, lacks the emotional depth and build-up that characterized her previous relationship with Andy. The declarations of love between Haley and Arvind feel somewhat rushed and unearned, especially when compared to the carefully constructed and emotionally resonant arc with Andy. The return of Adam Devine as Andy in this episode is a welcome cameo, but also serves as a reminder of what Modern Family season 9 could have been. The on-screen chemistry between Hyland and Devine was undeniable, and their storyline remains a highlight of the show’s more recent seasons. The lingering sense that there are no plans to revisit this pairing feels like a missed opportunity to recapture the show’s former comedic and emotional highs.
In conclusion, “The Escape,” like much of Modern Family season 9, is a mixed bag. The episode reinforces the prevailing criticism that the show has lost its way, relying on tired tropes and unlikeable character interactions for humor. The exception, and perhaps the only compelling reason to continue watching Modern Family season 9, remains Haley Dunphy. Sarah Hyland’s consistently excellent performance and Haley’s positive character evolution offer fleeting moments of genuine entertainment amidst a sea of familial discord and forced comedy. While “The Escape” may not be a complete write-off thanks to Haley, it does little to alleviate concerns about the overall direction of Modern Family as it progresses through season 9.
